Messages started flying weeks before the event to the 30+ women on the Facebook page: Who can attend? Who is baking cookies? Which ones? Who is making what for the lunch buffet? Will we be wearing our Christmas sweaters? Who is bringing a Christmas tree ornament for the exchange?
It’s a hodgepodge of posts and replies that only a seasoned strategist could navigate, and that person is my cousin, Jodi Shinoski-McFarland, the hostess.
The Polish Princess Polish Christmas Party is held in Belmont, Ohio, and has been going on since 2008 for the families in the area. About five years ago the shout-out went wider, but I was living out west and unable to attend, though my sisters did, since 2021. Last year was my first time going, and it is a connection that needs to endure.
This year’s party had fewer attendees than last year, but more poignancy. We lost two of last year’s participants, the last surviving Shinoski sibling, Uncle Joe, and our oldest cousin, Barb, but felt their proximity. We also felt the closeness of all our ancestors as we flipped through cousin Sandy’s photo album.


My mom, Josephine, was one of eight Shinoski children and left Fairpoint, Ohio, in the late 1940s. Most of her siblings stayed in the area. One brother, Ginger, died in World War II in Italy, a hole in her heart that never closed. One sister, Helen, followed her to Philly, and a brother, Andy, settled in Connecticut, but the majority found employment in the coal region and continued their Polish traditions in the sleepy village dominated by St. Joseph’s Catholic Church on the hill and the Polish club across the railroad tracks by the ballfield.
Growing up, we spent our summers in Fairpoint with Babci and tons of cousins. Later, our connection was limited to big Polish weddings or Easter holidays.
I’m very happy to reconnect with those cousins again.
People are invited for 11 a.m., and the appetizers crowd the counter. Jodi has more Polish pottery than anywhere this side of Warsaw, and it is all in use at the party.



At noon, the lids came off the crockpots, and the casserole dishes came out of the oven with a flourish. There’s not one cabbage roll dish, there are two, one with tomato sauce and one without. The pork, sauerkraut, and kielbasa sits next to a bowl of fluffy mashed potatoes. Sophie’s Meatballs, recreated by her daughter Becky, and potato and cheese pierogies are next to each other like the cousins who made them.






On the side, there’s a palate-cleansing array of veggies, fruit, and a White Chicken Chili for a change of taste.





To keep it all healthy, there is an assortment of salads.



We did the ornament exchange after lunch, to burn some calories while passing around the wrapped bags as Jodi reads a complicated list of instructions from a website designed to orchestrate ornament swaps.




And then we got to the cookies. Last year, the cookies served were all together and we filled our plates, bags, or containers with 6 of each. This year, everyone brought eight or nine dozen in individual containers. But I missed that memo and brought Ziploc bags of my little Fur Trees (groundhog cookie dough shaped into trees but furry looking thanks to the egg wash on the dough).


Our cousin Kelly provided the cookie centerpiece, with fancifully decorated cookies that tasted as good as they looked. It was a labor of love that we all enjoyed. The youngest among us, almost-2-year-old Cooper, my cousin Mark’s great-grandson, was fascinated by the platter and had his eye on the red pickup truck while his mom, Haley, gently steered him to a smaller snowman.
As the party wound down, we watched the soccer game with our cousin Marianna’s daughter playing for the Washington Spirit, the team that beat the Utah Royals in a playoff semifinal. Andi Sullivan must have heard us cheering her on.



As I was leaving, I spotted a very intriguing book on the coffee table. My cousin Sandy told me that she and Jodi had attended a Wedding Cookie Table Community (WCTC) event held near Pittsburgh last April. The group has a Facebook page and hosts events throughout the year, including the world’s largest Christmas cookie exchange.


The tradition of a cookie table for weddings has roots in western Pa., particularly Pittsburgh, as well as in Youngstown, Ohio, and Wheeling, West Virginia. These are my people! Expect more on this topic when I get a chance to do a deep dive and attend one of their events.
By the time we arrived home, both my sister and I were members of the WCTC FB group that posts recipes and tips about cookie baking.
’Tis the season! Thanks for warming us up, Jodi. And thanks to all the cousins who attended and shared the tradition. Special thanks to Cooper for making us see the joy of the holiday through his young and eager eyes.
Here’s a recipe from the party.









